Let's Stay Together- Should I Contest the Divorce
You have been served with a summons in connection with a divorce action -what do you do?
You must immediately decide whether you will be contesting the divorce. In doing so, you will have to determine whether the marriage is dead, whether the marriage is salvageable and to attempt reconciliation or whether you will need to contest the divorce for other reasons.
Reconciliation requires cooperation. If you spouse does not want to reconcile, there may be nothing you can do to salvage the marriage. You can contest the divorce, but even if you prevail and the divorce is denied, you cannot force your spouse to live with you or to revive the marital relationship. You will be married in name and legal effect only.
You should be acutely aware that by the time you have been served with the divorce papers, your spouse has, in all likelihood, consulted with an attorney, paid a retainer, and filed a summons seeking a divorce in court. You may surmise that this person does not really want to be with you.
By contesting a divorce, you force your spouse to prove, at trial, each and every element of their grounds for divorce. That is they must prove all of the jurisdictional requirements (the reason the court has the authority to hear the case and render a judgment) and all of the elements for grounds for divorce (i.e., adultery, cruel and inhuman treatment, abandonment for a year or an imprisonment). So, for instance, if the divorce is based upon the grounds of abandonment, you spouse must prove that for a year before he/she commenced the divorce, without excuse or justification, you continuously abandoned him/her.
If you agree that the marriage is over, but there are other unresolved issues relating to the children of the marriage, visitation, child support, equitable distribution of property, spousal maintenance or any other issue, you should contest the divorce. The court can bifurcate the trial. In other words, the court can separate the issues that the parties agree on, say, for instance, to divorce, but address only the issues in dispute, generally the economic issues or the issues related to the care and custody of the children. No divorce will be granted until all the issues have been resolved by trial or agreement.
Suppose, however, that you agree the marriage is over, but not for the reasons alleged by your spouse. For example, the husband alleges he was abandoned by the wife. In reality, the husband not only abandoned the Wife, but moved in with another woman, whose child he fathered. The Wife, in this example, could counterclaim that the Husband abandoned the Wife and also committed adultery. At trial, each party would have the opportunity to prove his or her case in order to obtain a divorce. If either party sustains his/her burden of proof, a divorce will be granted. Conversely, if neither proves his/her case, both will be denied a divorce.
In making the decision whether to contest the divorce, the party should carefully consider all of the issues to be resolved in connection the divorce, the available options, the likelihood of success on the merits, and the costs involved in defending the action.
In the end, in deciding to contest a divorce on the merits, you must answer the fundamental question, do you want to continue a martial relationship, with someone who does not want to be with you. A successful defense of an action for divorce, does not rekindle the marital flam
View My LinkedIn Profile
Follow me on Twitter
Married in NY Fan Page
Comments (12)
Read through and enter the discussion by using the form at the endAmanda - January 3, 2007 5:56 AM
If one person is sure she wants the divorce but her husband refuses, can he keep her from divorcing him?
beverly - January 16, 2007 8:22 AM
can a wife contest a divorce for 7 yrs to get the benefits of husband's full military pension?
a cukr - May 11, 2007 3:18 AM
I read your article about should I contest the divorce? If a person does not contest a claim of cruel and inhuman treatment, does that not constitute tacit agreement? Could that be held against that person in a later proceeding - say over child custody? My brother is being pushed to accept divorce on the grounds of cruel and inhuman treatment - they are calling it mutual cruel and inhuman treatment. Is that possible in New York State? Please help!
Daniel Clement - May 11, 2007 12:36 PM
Normally, since New York does not have a "no-fault" grounds for divorce, agreeing to a fault based ground as no consequence on the other issues. That said, I do not know what was alleged in your brother's case. I suggest this be discussed with his attorney.
Daniel Clement
Debbie - June 28, 2007 9:06 PM
can a unknowlegeable divorce with children involve be contested and under what grounds. party is already remarried.
Linda - July 9, 2007 10:01 AM
If one person is sure she wants the divorce but her husband refuses, can he keep her from divorcing him?
Janet - February 1, 2008 2:07 AM
My husband had filed for divorce and I contested it. For three years we were in court, and then I made an agreement with my soon to be ex and then I agreed to no longer contest the divorce. After signing the divorce papers, my husband wanted to get back together. Lucky for us, the court founded a problem with the language on the divorce decree and so the divorce was still in limbo. We called our attornies and we were able to cancel the process, with a stipulation that we have a year to change our minds . It has been four years since then and we are still happy......
marty cohen - August 18, 2008 11:07 AM
I read the questions people are asking. Hope you've answered theirs and that you will answer mine.
I live in Colorado, and my spouse has relocated to Nebraska. We seem
to be of the same mind when it comes to cohabiting. It's no longer a viable option.
However, health insurance is the major issue for me. Is there a way for me to be divorced and remain insured under my spouse's plan?
M. Cohen
Rebecca - November 11, 2008 12:14 PM
my husband and i have been separated for a little over two years he moved back to New Hampshire from kansas about a year ago, we have been in contact on a regular basis saying the i love yous and miss yous, but he has influences like a best friend and a mother that dont want to lose him again in other words move away which was always his idea, so they have basically convinced him to move on.we still love each other the love is stong but i think he has decided to take a different path I DONT WANT A DIVORCE..I went for a visit a couple of weeks ago do you think his mom or friend would let us have more the 2hrs together in fear i would change his mind ...i was there for a week got to see him twice..im just gonna keep on contesting it i dont care how long it takes hes gonna know im not going anywhere he is my life and bestfriend...and this has only happened because of the influences around him if you truely love someone and believe you r meant to be togethr by all means you keep fighting for your love
Rebecca - November 11, 2008 12:15 PM
my husband and i have been separated for a little over two years he moved back to New Hampshire from kansas about a year ago, we have been in contact on a regular basis saying the i love yous and miss yous, but he has influences like a best friend and a mother that dont want to lose him again in other words move away which was always his idea, so they have basically convinced him to move on.we still love each other the love is stong but i think he has decided to take a different path I DONT WANT A DIVORCE..I went for a visit a couple of weeks ago do you think his mom or friend would let us have more the 2hrs together in fear i would change his mind ...i was there for a week got to see him twice..im just gonna keep on contesting it i dont care how long it takes hes gonna know im not going anywhere he is my life and bestfriend...and this has only happened because of the influences around him if you truely love someone and believe you r meant to be togethr by all means you keep fighting for your love
lorie - January 30, 2009 2:59 PM
I want a divorce and started the process my x to be contested it. What do I do now? I don't want him and I asked for nothing at the time but he left and left me with all of the bills we have no children together but I have one I just wanted it over but he won't let me go. Do I ask for what he owes me. and how can I get this done fast and with little money. I live in NY state
Dionne - May 6, 2010 10:38 AM
My infants father married his girlfriend years ago. He is not a citizen. She is verbally abusive and obsessivly controlling. He went back to her and tried to work the marriage out and fathered a child with her and nothing has changed with her attitude as a matter of fact it worst because he is living with her and her parents due to financial hardship so shes even worst than before. He states they argue everyday even over sex position! When we met he was in the process of divorce which she was contesting..he says now' she states "if you bring divorce papers to me again, I will tear them up!" He wants to divorce her and file for citizenship as well. What to do? She is trying to keep up this image to her friends and family that they are a happily married couple and for those reasons it seems she can not let go.. and he is emotionally dettached already.